TTEC Holdings, Inc. (NASDAQ:TTEC) has continued to provide damaging outcomes for shareholders regardless of a 4.87% dividend yield.
I beforehand wrote about TTEC with a Maintain outlook attributable to purchasers delaying discretionary initiatives and exerting extra scrutiny over current and new undertaking engagements.
Demand continues to stay tender, and AI initiatives are principally simply pilots, so I see nothing within the close to time period to drag TTEC Holdings, Inc. out of the doldrums.
Subsequently, I reiterate my outlook on TTEC for the close to time period as Impartial [Hold].
TTEC’s Method And Market
TTEC’s foremost service choices embody an omnichannel buyer expertise technique, associated expertise improvement, and outsourcing/managed companies.
The corporate has a devoted in-house gross sales group that targets potential purchasers and gives them with tailor-made options.
Per a 2023 market analysis report by Grand View Analysis, the worldwide marketplace for digital transformation consulting was an estimated $731 billion in 2022 and is predicted to achieve $4.9 trillion by 2030.
This represents a forecast CAGR of 26.7% from 2023 to 2030.
The primary motive for this anticipated development in IT consulting is a multi-decade transition by organizations from on-premises, legacy methods to cloud-based environments with advanced architectures.
This anticipated development is more likely to proceed throughout all trade verticals and in authorities businesses as nicely.
The COVID-19 pandemic boosted the consulting trade as organizations expedited their digital transformation efforts.
Recently, corporations have begun to dip their toe in AI-related engagements, however have targeted on cost-takeout work and AI that improves customer support, which represents easy-to-approve contracts for money flow-conscious purchasers.
The chart beneath exhibits the historic and projected future development trajectory of the U.S. digital transformation market from 2020 to 2030:
Main aggressive or different trade members embody:
-
Globant
-
Thoughtworks
-
EPAM
-
Slalom
-
Accenture
-
Deloitte Digital
-
McKinsey
-
BCG
-
Ideo
-
Cognizant Expertise Options
-
Capgemini
-
Pc Job Group
-
Firm in-house improvement efforts.
The agency can also be lively within the buyer expertise companies outsourcing market, which is a $270 billion worldwide market.
TTEC Holdings’ Current Monetary Tendencies
Whole income by quarter (columns) has stagnated attributable to lowered or delayed shopper demand for companies in a worsening macroeconomic atmosphere; Working earnings by quarter (line) has dropped in latest quarters due to worse gross revenue efficiency.
Gross revenue by quarter (inexperienced line) has worsened and administration is implementing plans for value reductions, however these plans gained’t enhance outcomes till 2024; Promoting and G&A bills as a share of whole income by quarter (burgundy line) have fallen as revenues have dropped attributable to elevated offshore combine.
Earnings per share (Diluted) have additionally fallen sharply in latest quarters because of the general falloff in demand from purchasers focusing extra on cost-takeout initiatives.
(All information within the above charts is GAAP).
Prior to now 12 months, TTEC’s inventory worth has fallen 51.6% vs. that of the SPDR S&P Software program & Companies ETF’s (XSW) rise of 38.6%, so the corporate’s outcomes have diverged sharply from a wider trade benchmark:
For steadiness sheet outcomes, the agency ended the quarter with $151.6 million in money and equivalents and $964.0 million in whole debt, all of which was categorized as long-term.
Over the trailing twelve months, free money stream was $57.3 million, throughout which capital expenditures had been $74.2 million. The corporate paid $20.7 million in stock-based compensation within the final 4 quarters.
TTEC’s Valuation Metrics
The desk beneath exhibits a variety of related and useful firm efficiency metrics as indicated:
Metric |
Quantity |
EV/Gross sales (“FWD”) |
0.8 |
EV/EBITDA (“FWD”) |
7.3 |
Worth/Gross sales (“TTM”) |
0.4 |
Income Progress (“YoY”) |
4.1% |
Internet Earnings Margin |
1.6% |
EBITDA Margin |
11.1% |
Market Capitalization |
$1,050,000,000 |
Enterprise Worth |
$2,020,000,000 |
Working Money Circulate |
$131,470,000 |
Earnings Per Share (Absolutely Diluted) |
$0.86 |
2024 FWD EPS Estimate |
$2.14 |
Rev. Progress Estimate (“FWD”) |
2.6% |
Free Money Circulate/Share (“TTM”) |
$1.21 |
Looking for Alpha Quant Rating |
Sturdy Promote – 1.38 |
(Supply – Looking for Alpha).
Beneath is an estimated DCF (Discounted Money Circulate) evaluation of the agency’s projected development and earnings:
Primarily based on the DCF, utilizing a reduction charge of 11% (10-year Treasury at 4% plus 7% fairness danger premium) and ahead earnings per share assumption of $2.14, the agency’s shares could be valued at roughly $21.72 versus the present worth of $21.62, indicating they’re probably presently totally valued.
Additionally, in comparison with Conduent Integrated (CNDT), the next desk exhibits varied main metrics:
Metric |
Conduent |
TTEC Holdings |
Variance |
EV/Gross sales (“FWD”) |
0.6 |
0.8 |
50.9% |
EV/EBITDA (“FWD”) |
5.9 |
7.3 |
24.6% |
Rev. Progress Estimate (“FWD”) |
-3.2% |
2.6% |
–% |
Internet Earnings Margin |
-16.9% |
1.6% |
–% |
Working Money Circulate |
$18,000,000 |
$131,470,000 |
630.4% |
(Supply: Looking for Alpha)
The valuation comparability to Conduent signifies that TTEC seems totally valued given its optimistic ahead income development estimate and optimistic web earnings margin.
Why TTEC Is Having A Troublesome Time
TTEC is affected by tender demand from purchasers as they concentrate on non-discretionary initiatives and delay discretionary engagements.
Income has risen just one.8% YoY, whereas gross revenue margin has dropped by 3.5%.
Consequently, working earnings has fallen 22.2% from a 12 months in the past.
Whereas curiosity in AI improvement stays robust, curiosity has been largely restricted to pilot testing solely, as purchasers take a gradual strategy to adopting these new applied sciences.
The issue for consulting-oriented corporations comparable to TTEC is {that a} slower strategy from purchasers reduces their worker utilization charge whereas they await shopper demand to rebound.
If administration believes the downturn might be short-lived, they are going to search to retain as many staff as attainable to place the corporate for a rebound in demand.
This could produce a state of affairs the place there’s a mismatch between income demand drop however retention of a better value construction whereas ready for demand to extend.
Additionally, throughout downturns, prospects concentrate on cost-takeout efforts, which are likely to have short-term outcomes however is probably not as profitable for consulting and improvement corporations.
The agency has operations in quite a few areas worldwide, however its abroad engagements are usually smaller in dimension, so are probably much less leverageable into large-scale alternatives.
Administration stated its “offshore pipeline is up greater than 50% in comparison with final 12 months,” a vibrant spot of types.
Moreover, its general pipeline for the subsequent six months is “above $1 billion,” however whereas migrations confirmed rising manufacturing, bookings have seen delays, as mentioned above.
The agency’s Cisco work continues to drop, which is a major drag on its recurring income stream.
So, consulting agency buyers have a “crystal ball” downside, which is whether or not you imagine the demand downturn might be “brief and shallow,” by which case you purchase on momentary weak point, or “longer and deeper,” by which case you’ll keep away from the corporate and sector.
For my part, quite a few consulting corporations who’re experiencing the identical common demand softness, I’m not sure that the softness might be short-lived, so I’m extra cautious.
Whereas AI-related initiatives are a possible vibrant spot, they aren’t turning into huge demand…but.
Longer-term, I imagine the AI phase will produce development for consulting & improvement corporations, however I don’t assume the shopper base demand for full-on transformation is producing topline development for consulting and improvement corporations.
I see no main upside catalyst to the inventory within the close to time period, however buyers may even see some potential upward trajectory within the again half of 2024, assuming the downturn in demand is short-lived.
My base case is for continued gradual development for TTEC, with sagging working earnings efficiency because the enterprise atmosphere grinds slowly within the subsequent a number of quarters at the very least.
Subsequently, my outlook on TTEC Holdings, Inc. is to reiterate my earlier Impartial – Maintain place on continued demand softness and full valuation.